Variations in Velocity July 7, 2016
This research project was established to determine if there was a predictable measurable velocity difference directly proportional to minor variations in inside case capacity for the .308 Winchester rifle cartridge.
All too often I’ve sat at my shooting bench looking at my chronograph numbers wondering why the heck I sometimes see 20+ fps variations in well-built .308 Winchester rifle rounds. What I mean by well-built is as follows. Cases were from the same lot, each was previously fired 2x, cleaned, lubed, sized properly with .004 headspace, trimmed with L.E.Wilson precision trimmer, flash hole uniformed, primer pockets cut, case mouths deburred, primed with match primers, powder loaded to .01 grain and bullets were seated to a previously proven optimal seating depth. All finished rounds were measured for concentricity and trued to .001 or better.
Experimentation Process and Steps*
On order to determine the cause of these variations, I have setup the following experiment. Each step is logged.
1) Select 5 Nosler .308 Winchester cases from the same batch.
2) Number each case 1 through 5 with permanent marker to eliminate any mix-ups
3) Weigh each case “post clean” with spent primers to create baseline weight before and after resizing
4) Weigh each case “post clean” with spent primers filled with water (same meniscus, see references) before and after resizing
5) Measure length of Headspace before and after resizing
6) Measure case length after resizing
7) Weight Sort Hornady 168 match bullets to find 8 with same weight
8) Take 8 sorted bullets and measure each to select 5 with the same length from base to Ogive
9) Install Federal 210M primers in numbered and fully prepped cases
10) Dispense exactly 46.02 grains of CFE223 powder into each case
11) Seat the 5 bullets using the L.E.Wilson micrometer seating die to 2.2705” seating depth
12) Weigh each completed cartridge
13) Measure bullet runout but do not correct (to ensure no possible change in neck tension)
14) Measure completed bullet neck with bullet installed and record
1) Load and fire two fouling rounds composed of same bullet, powder and primer before measuring velocity
2) Fire each of the 5 test rounds with a 5 minute cooling period between each shot
3) Measure velocity via chronograph and record results
4) Determine if cases with lower capacity showed higher velocity and larger capacity showed lower velocity
5) Document results, draw conclusions and publish findings
*Each measurement was performed several times to ensure accuracy and consistency.
Cases with the smallest case capacities should show an increase in pressure. The increased pressure should result in a higher velocity reading as the bullet passes through the chronograph.
There are items that could cause issues with the results. Most are due to factors beyond my control. Several are: Variations smaller than the Chronograph can measure, variations in primer performance, variations in the bullet cores, minor variations in barrel conditions shot to shot, etc)
The Following are the actual measurements take throughout the process.
CONCLUSIONS FROM ACTUAL TEST RESULTS
After each round was fired, the rifle was allowed to cool for 5 min. before the next round was fired. Temperature was 70 degrees with moderate humidity. Bench 45 was in the shade and rifle was not subjected to direct sunlight.
Show in the table above, test CASE #4 had the smallest case capacity AND showed the highest velocity. The third largest (Case #3) and fourth largest (CASE #2) cases also provide the 3rd and 4th highest velocity respectively. Test CASE #1 and #5 deviated from expected result. I will need to look at these two cases to determine if there is any visible reason for these two variations. The difference in velocities could also be due to some of the factor beyond my control.
I do believe this test provides 60% validation that there is a direct correlation between internal case capacity and velocity variations, even within the same batch of very well made match quality cases.
Every journey begins with a step. Now, you can take that step whenever you're ready with our new "Beginner to Advanced" program. Don't let calendars get in the way, we offer classes each month for beginner, intermediate and advanced alike. Special calibers are no challenge, 223, 308, 6.5 Creedmoor, 9mm, 45 ACP, 338 Lapua, we cover most all. Contact us for any special calibers or unique training requests.
"Thanks to your training, I am now reloading and getting 0.3 to 0.6 MOA shooting prone with bipod"
- Jose S.
"I flew in from out of state, stayed at a local hotel only 5 min from class, had dinner out with my classmates and enjoyed the best course I've ever taken"
- Mike T.
"My husband and I really loved the course. It allowed us to learn together and share the experience!"
- Toni & Nick P.
Illinois Reloading Institute
Grayslake, IL. United States
Copyright Illinois Reloading Institute
All Rights Reserved.
At the Illinois Reloading Instruction Lab we're harnessing the power of the NRA Basic Metallic Reloading Course, and offering new, innovative ways of mastering these skills. Combining the newest reloading research with proven teaching methodology, we're inspiring students to master the skills needed to safely develop high quality ammunition.